Who Gives and Who Takes Away?
Every day, someone has something taken away. Possessions, health, life. Since time began, people have assumed that whatever god they know is behind these losses. Here is one example in a description of ancient Mesopotamians’ beliefs:
The religion of the ancient Sumerians has left its mark on the entire middle east. . . . the gods controlled the powerful forces which often dictated a human's fate. . . . Although the gods preferred justice and mercy, they had also created evil and misfortune. A Sumerian had little that he could do about it. Judging from Lamentation records, the best one could do in times of duress would be to "plead, lament and wail, tearfully confessing his sins and failings." Their family god or city god might intervene on their behalf, but that would not necessarily happen. After all, man was created as a broken, labor saving, tool for the use of the gods and at the end of everyone's life, lay the underworld, a generally dreary place. (Wolkstein & Kramer 1983: pp.123-124)
The man Job lived in the time of the patriarchs (dates range from 2100-1000 BC), likely east of the river Jordan (the same broad region as the Sumerians, but perhaps several hundred miles west). He may have lived to be 180-200 years old (he lived 140 years after the events described in the book of Job). When he experienced a “taking away” of major proportions, he came to the same conclusion: God had done it:
"The Lord gave, and the Lord hath taken away; Blessed be the name of the Lord." - Job
Job is a hero of faith. He did not have the written word of God to refer to, he didn’t have friends who understood God – he didn’t even have the benefit of a Godly soulmate to walk with him through his struggle.
Just as today we often give in to the natural human tendency to make God in our culture’s image, how much more would Job be influenced by the beliefs of surrounding cultures, without any written word of God to serve as compass? I think it is extraordinary that he held to his faith in God as he did, given what must have been his contextual understanding of what “gods” were thought to be like.
For example, Job did not have these words:
“If anyone does attack you, it will not be my doing.”- Isaiah, quoting God
“The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full.” - Jesus
“If you, then, though you are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father in heaven give good gifts to those who ask him!”- Jesus
"Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and cometh down from the Father of lights, with whom is no variableness, neither shadow of turning." - James
Job did not have all these Scriptures. But we do. I believe many people assume that because Job's words about God giving and taking away are recorded in the Bible, they are a true expression of God's character. But the Bible contains many things people said which are not necessarily true, but are an accurate historical record of that person's experience and opinion, which God intended for us to learn from but not necessarily emulate. The next time something is taken away from you, will you believe that your loss is God's will, simply because it has happened?
“Blessed be the name of the Lord . . . Who gives and takes away . . .” - sung by millions of Christians in your church and mine, AD 2006
I know, it’s a great song and deserves to be sung often – all but those two words. My nine-year-old told me he made up his own version: “He GIVES and MAKES A WAY . . .”
Job did not know any better than to think that God is the one who gives and takes away. But we should.
This has everything to do with receiving healing – or any of God’s promises. If you believe God is the Taker, you will receive illness as a “hidden blessing” from God. I have seen many Christians do this, and like Job, I believe they too are heroic, showing enormous character in the face of suffering. They show extraordinary faith to love a God who would hurt them so. I respect their courage.
But I disagree with the premise on which this belief is founded. I do not believe the Bible presents God as a Taker, but as a Giver.
If, on the other hand, you believe that the Taker is a thief – the thief who comes to kill, steal, and destroy, if you believe that satan is a roaring lion who devours whomever he can get his claws on, then you will respond very differently to any crisis.
171 Comments:
Thanks for a thought-provoking and insightful post! I confess I've always found that line of the song jarring. It sounds like we're supposed be happy when something is taken from us, and we're supposed to credit God with doing so. I like your nine-year-old's version much better (in fact I wonder why the songwriter didn't come up with that line to begin with).
generic valium normal dosage valium - valium side effects itching
tramadol no prescription kind pill tramadol hcl - tramadol hcl back pain
tramadol 50 tramadol 50 mg kapsler - tramadol 50mg tab
buy tramadol online tramadol vs percocet high - tramadol high experience
buy discount tramadol buy 300 mg tramadol - reputable online pharmacy tramadol
order tramadol online overnight tramadol tablets dogs dosage - legal buy tramadol online us
buy tramadol 180 buy cheap tramadol online usa - tramadol hcl oral tablet 50 mg
tramadol cheap tramadol without prescription - buy tramadol legit
generic ativan ativan in alcohol withdrawal - ativan quitting
buy tramadol without rx tramadol rxlist - can get high tramadol hydrochloride
tramadol without prescription order tramadol online reviews - taking 100mg tramadol
klonopin online klonopin side effects eyes - klonopin withdrawal melatonin
purchase tramadol tramadol can you snort - buy tramadol 180
buy tramadol no prescription tramadol dosage adults - tramadol hcl 50mg get you high
buy klonopin klonopin withdrawal back pain - klonopin 13
ativan no prescription ativan dosage dental surgery - ativan dosage 6 mg
buy tramadol saturday delivery tramadol 100mg vs vicodin - buy tramadol online without prescriptions
buy tramadol rx buy ultram no prescription - tramadol hcl side effects
where to buy tramadol buy tramadol order cheap tramadol online - tramadol 50mg can you snort
buying ambien online dosage of ambien for sleep - ambien and alcohol withdrawal
cheap klonopin online overdose of klonopin amount - klonopin for anxiety as needed
tramadol online buy tramadol paypal - tramadol hcl buy
carisoprodol online what are soma pills for - soma brave new world
buy lorazepam online side effects getting off ativan - ativan side effects elderly patients
generic ambien ambien side effects in children - not now ambien walrus toothpaste dinner
zolpidem without prescription ambien side effects shaking - side effects mixing ambien xanax
ativan lorazepam ativan vs xanax for anxiety - ativan overdose with alcohol
buy tramadol where can i order tramadol - order tramadol with money order
order klonopin online high on klonopin - death from klonopin overdose
buy generic tramadol buy cheap tramadol online uk - buy ultram er canada
online soma getting high soma drug - soma 7 panel drug test
cheap tramadol tramadol dosage compared vicodin - tramadol hcl acetaminophen 650
can you buy ambien online ambien side effects throwing up - ambien pill identification
tramadol no rx tramadol 50 mg drug interactions - tramadol 50 mg price per pill
generic ambien get ambien online - drug interactions propranolol ambien
tramadol generic tramadol 50 mg canine - buy tramadol discover card
tramadol online where is a good place to buy tramadol online - buy ultram cheap
buy soma buy cheap generic soma - buy soma drug
buy viagra cialis online viagra results - safe purchase viagra online
order viagra online from canada online pharmacy viagra fast delivery - viagra next day delivery
buy tramadol 180 buy tramadol dogs uk - tramadol dosage for high
buy soma online drug interactions soma benadryl - buy soma online from usa
buy viagra online buy viagra canada pharmacy - viagra for women online
tramadol online overnight tramadol hcl 40 mg - buy tramadol 50mg uk
buy tramadol online no prescription buy tramadol 50mg uk - tramadol hcl uses
order zolpidem generic ambien cost at walmart - took 4 ambien cr
tramadol online cheap tramadol cod delivery - tramadol withdrawal high blood pressure
generic soma online online pharmacy soma no prescription - buy soma online mastercard
viagra online buy viagra 25 mg - legal order viagra online canada
generic carisoprodol soma bras usanapolis - generic version of soma
ambien online no prescription ambien side effects paranoia - ambien vs xanax insomnia
cheap zolpidem ambien withdrawal rash - zolpidem tartrate side effects
online soma buy soma florida - soma san diego last.fm
cheapest ambien zolpidem ambien used - order ambien online usa
buy tramadol online tramadol 50mg or 100mg - buy tramadol without rx
can you buy viagra at walmart generic viagra uk - order viagra nz
klonopin for anxiety klonopin qualitest - klonopin side effects espanol
generic ambien withdrawal symptoms of ambien cr - ambien cr generic equivalent
tramadol overnight shipping legal buy tramadol online - cheap tramadol without rx
order soma online cheap hotels soma - soma 12 panel drug test
buy viagra online buy viagra now net - cheap viagra in india
buy klonopin online overnight vicodin klonopin erowid - klonopin order online no prescription
ambien sleep ambien pill 73 - ambien online no rx
ambien order online no prescription mexican pharmacy ambien - death by ambien overdose
soma online soma bras washington dc - generic soma 350
order soma online soma medication dosage - buy soma online no prescription needed
buy viagra online cheap can u buy viagra at walmart - buy viagra legally online
buy carisoprodol online generic soma - soma medication buy online
buy cialis 20mg where to buy cialis online in canada - get prescription cialis online
buy cialis no prescription cialis jelly - price of cialis vs viagra
buy cheap tramadol tramadol 50mg hcl - buy tramadol online
soma online discount soma no prescription - soma pills brave new world
buy viagra online viagra online uk - order viagra online without script
sildenafil no prescription viagra online pharmacy canada - buy generic viagra fast shipping
buy soma online no prescription aura soma 89 - what is soma for muscle relaxer
soma online pharmacy buy soma online overnight - how to buy somatropin in usa
order viagra cheap purchase viagra united states - viagra online for women
buy tramadol without a script buy tramadol 50mg net - best place buy tramadol online reviews
cheap viagra pills buy viagra safely online - viagra for women sale
purchase tramadol tramadol ingredients codeine - where to buy tramadol safely
buy viagra online generic viagra levitra cialis - buy viagra uk quick delivery
tramadol online can buy tramadol online usa - tramadol for dogs taste
propecia hair loss propecia quotes - propecia side effects wiki
buy tramadol online tramadol long term use - tramadol for dogs arthritis
viagra pills viagra 7 11 - viagra online germany
buy viagra online usa buy viagra online generic - buy cheap viagra online from india
buy tramadol hcl tramadol 100 mg lp - tramadol 50 mg long term use
tramadol overnight shipping buy tramadol with paypal - tramadol buy online no prescription mastercard
buy viagra buy viagra hong kong - generic viagra cialis or levitra online
retin a buy online retin-a micro gel instructions - retin a gel for sale
viagra pharmacy buy viagra online women - buying viagra from canada
tramadol online no prescription tramadol hcl for pain - buy online texas tramadol
propecia without prescription propecia low testosterone - bad results propecia
propecia online propecia side effects depression - propecia gay
buy tramadol tramadol qatar - tramadol 50mg what are they for
tramadol 50 mg buy tramadol hydrochloride online - tramadol 50 mg vs norco
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online with cod - tramadol ultram high
tramadol 50mg tramadol 25mg tablets - mexican tramadol 100mg
buy tramadol buy tramadol cod next day delivery - what are the best sites to buy tramadol online
propecia online buy propecia 5mg online - propecia infertility
buy retin-a retin-a how to use - buying retin a in usa
tramadol 50mg tramadol withdrawal xanax - generic brand tramadol
buy tramadol cod online tramadol 37.5 mg - tramadol 50mg capsules uses
tramadol 50 mg buy tramadol online no prescription mastercard - buy tramadol online next day delivery
buy tramadol tramadol equivalent - purchase cheap tramadol online
tramadol without prescription buy tramadol online with paypal - tramadol prescription
buy tramadol cod next day delivery tramadol capsules 50mg for dogs - tramadol dosage rat
tramadol online tramadol for dogs kidney failure - where to buy tramadol usa
tramadol 50mg buy tramadol online us - tramadol 50 mg tablets side effects
buy propecia online propecia 1 mg buy - propecia side effects go away
order tramadol online mastercard tramadol purchase cheap - tramadol 50 mg and ibuprofen
tramadol 50 mg buy-tramadol-online.org - tramadol 50 mg and ibuprofen
order tramadol online order tramadol online saturday delivery - buy tramadol an 627
buy cialis without doctor prescription cialis online with paypal - how well does cialis daily work
buy generic viagra buy viagra or cialis online - buy viagra online ehow
generic viagra online legal order viagra online us - buy viagra online us no prescription
buy tramadol ultram 100mg online - tramadol high 100mg
viagra no prescription buy cheap viagra online us - buy viagra now us
generic cialis buy cialis online canada - cialis daily use benefits
buy tramadol tramadol information - buy viagra tramadol
cheap cialis online buy cialis online usa - canadian cialis reviews
viagra online without prescription viagra kwikmed - viagra dosage experience
viagra 50mg viagra dosage maximum - buy viagra with paypal
cialis 20mg cialis daily use review - cialis daily for men
buy tramadol tramadol tablets - buy tramadol from india
generic cialis cheap cialis reviews - cialis daily instructions
order viagra online legit online pharmacy viagra - viagra 8000mg
buy cialis generic generic cialis forums - cialis vs levitra
discount viagra buy viagra us only - purchase viagra with prescription
tadalafil 20mg cialis online united states - generic cialis paypal
cialis online no prescription buy viagra cialis online - http://www.cialis-online-shop.com
buy cheap cialis cialis online+toronto - buy generic cialis online canada
generic cialis cialis online legit - buy cialis online uk no prescription
buy soma online legitimate online soma - soma drug class florida
viagra online buy viagra online australia no prescription - buy viagra online legitimate
viagra online viagra in us prescription required - generic viagra online us no prescription
buy cialis cialis price lilly - generic cialis mail order
cialis price how quickly does cialis daily work - generic cialis warning
viagra online buy viagra women us - buy viagra online dublin
viagra online viagra rite aid - can you buy viagra online safely
buy soma online discount on soma intimates - watch deadly soma online
buy soma online soma muscle relaxer dosage - buy soma buena vista
soma generic soma edo - soma games
buy soma online much do soma cost - soma for muscle cramps
soma muscle relaxant company makes soma muscle relaxer - discount for soma
buy retin a retin-a effects - where to buy retin a online
soma online soma double cross - soma san diego logo
soma medication buy cheap generic soma - soma online overnight
soma online soma generic muscle relaxer - cheap holidays to soma bay egypt
buy soma online dragonica online soma - order soma from usa
buy soma soma junebug - soma drug test results
buy retin a retin a cream 0.025 reviews - retin a micro dosage
tadalafil 20mg cialis daily - cialis online with mastercard
buy tramadol online 4 50 mg tramadol - tramadol 50mg capsules dosage
buy tramadol where to buy tramadol online uk - tramadol dosage 500mg
buy tramadol without rx tramadol dosage per kg - buy tramadol next day delivery
buy tramadol online reviews tramadol dosage 37.5 - safe buy tramadol online
buy retin a gel retin a online usa - retin a 8 months
buy discount tramadol tramadol 50 mg vs tylenol #3 - buy tramadol 50mg online
buy retin a retin a micro dark spots - buy retin a micro 0.04 pump
buy tramadol online tramadol dosage overdose - tramadol 50 overdose
buy retin a what retin a micro gel used for - buy retin-a cream .05
order tramadol no prescription tramadol get high off - best place to buy tramadol online reviews
where to buy tramadol tramadol hcl 20mg - taking 2 50mg tramadol
buy tramadol cod fedex order tramadol online legal - can get high tramadol hydrochloride
tramadol 100 mg tramadol 50 mg high - 100mg of tramadol high
cheap tramadol tramadol online with cod - tramadol apap 37.5 dosage
cheap tramadol generic tramadol online - tramadol 50 mg how strong
tramadol online buy tramadol online no prescription usa - vicodin vs ultram tramadol
buy tramadol saturday delivery tramadol keeps me awake - tramadol addiction treatment centers
Post a Comment
<< Home